By Jim Baxter | JB Talking Sportz
If the College Football Playoff selection committee thought it had a pretty good handle on the nation’s best football teams when it released its rankings this week, Saturday should have provided a rather rude awakening.
College football has a wonderful way of making experts look foolish, and this weekend was a perfect example.
Georgia absolutely destroyed Ole Miss. Notre Dame knocked off top-ranked Miami. Oregon went into Columbus and embarrassed Ohio State. Texas kept its playoff hopes alive with a big road victory over Missouri, and UCLA continued its unbeaten march through the Big Ten.
Meanwhile, Alabama flexed its muscles against LSU, Tennessee dismantled Kentucky, and Utah survived another major test against BYU.
If you’re keeping score at home, that’s an awful lot of movement for a playoff picture the committee supposedly had figured out just a few days ago.
And I’ll tell you something else. There are a few teams in those rankings that have no business being where they are.
GEORGIA PUT OLE MISS IN A FREAKING BLENDER

I don’t know how else to describe what Georgia did to Ole Miss Saturday night.
The Bulldogs put the Rebels’ defense in a freaking blender.
Georgia didn’t just beat Ole Miss. The Bulldogs took a team ranked among the nation’s ten best and made it look completely overmatched.
This was supposed to be one of the premier matchups of the weekend. Instead, Kirby Smart’s Bulldogs turned it into a demonstration of what happens when a physical, talented football team imposes its will on an opponent that simply cannot respond.
And that’s what impressed me most about Georgia. This wasn’t about trick plays or gimmicks. This was about execution, physical superiority and an offensive attack that kept Ole Miss searching for answers it never found.
Georgia looked like a football team that understands exactly what it wants to accomplish offensively.
The Rebels looked like a football team that wished it could find the locker room.
I’ve said before that November is when championship-caliber teams begin separating themselves from the pretenders.
Georgia certainly made its case Saturday night.
NOTRE DAME EXPOSES THE COMMITTEE’S NO. 1 TEAM

Miami came into South Bend carrying the nation’s No. 1 ranking and all the expectations that accompany it.
Notre Dame didn’t particularly care.
The Fighting Irish knocked off the Hurricanes, delivering a victory that should send shock waves through the playoff rankings.
But here’s what bothers me about the committee’s initial evaluation.
Notre Dame entered the weekend ranked No. 11. Miami was No. 1.
That’s a ten-position separation between two teams that just demonstrated how competitive the upper tier of college football really is.
Now, I’m not suggesting one game should erase everything either team accomplished during the season. That’s not how rankings should work.
But I am suggesting the committee needs to take a serious look at how it evaluates quality wins, strength of schedule and actual performance against legitimate competition.
Notre Dame just gave the committee a pretty compelling argument.
And Miami? The Hurricanes are still a talented football team, but that No. 1 ranking is going to be awfully difficult to defend.
OREGON SENDS OHIO STATE INTO PLAYOFF PANIC

If you’re an Ohio State fan, Saturday was a nightmare.
Oregon walked into the Horseshoe and handed the Buckeyes a 41-28 defeat that could prove devastating to their postseason aspirations.
And here’s the problem for Ohio State. The Buckeyes entered the weekend ranked 12th.
They were already sitting on the edge of the playoff field.
Losing at home to a team ranked 23rd isn’t exactly the kind of performance that strengthens your résumé.
Oregon deserves tremendous credit. The Ducks weren’t intimidated by the environment, the helmets or the reputation of the program standing across from them.
They simply played better football.
The committee now faces an interesting dilemma. How much weight should it give Ohio State’s reputation compared to what Oregon demonstrated on the field?
Personally, I’ve always believed the name on the front of the jersey should matter considerably more than the tradition associated with it.
Oregon made its argument on the football field.
Ohio State is running out of opportunities to make its own.
TEXAS ISN’T GOING AWAY

Anybody who was ready to bury Texas might want to hold off on the funeral arrangements.
The Longhorns went into Missouri and came away with a 34-20 victory that keeps them squarely in the playoff conversation.
This was an important win because Texas couldn’t afford another stumble.
At this point in the season, style points are nice, but victories against quality conference opponents are considerably more valuable.
Texas handled its business.
The Longhorns still have work to do, but they’re very much alive.
UCLA AND UTAH KEEP ROLLING

While much of the attention was focused on the SEC and the chaos in Columbus and South Bend, two undefeated teams continued building impressive résumés.
UCLA defeated Minnesota 34-20, improving to 10-0 and keeping its perfect season intact.
Utah survived a difficult challenge from BYU, winning 28-20 in a game that carried enormous Big 12 implications.
Neither team should be overlooked.
I’ve always believed undefeated records deserve respect, particularly when teams continue winning against legitimate conference competition.
At some point, we have to stop talking about what teams might be capable of doing and start rewarding what they’ve actually accomplished.
UCLA and Utah have done nothing but win.
That ought to count for something.
ALABAMA AND TENNESSEE MAKE THEIR STATEMENTS

Alabama went into Baton Rouge and defeated LSU 31-13.
That’s a significant victory in one of college football’s most difficult environments, and it reinforces the Crimson Tide’s position among the serious playoff contenders.
Meanwhile, Tennessee absolutely hammered Kentucky 34-6.
That might be one of the more underrated results of the weekend.
Kentucky entered the game ranked sixth by the committee. Tennessee was 13th.
The Volunteers didn’t merely upset the Wildcats. They dominated them.
And that brings me right back to the committee.
If Kentucky was supposedly the sixth-best team in America, what exactly does Saturday’s performance tell us about Tennessee?
One game doesn’t define an entire season, but a 28-point defeat against a team ranked seven positions lower certainly deserves serious consideration.
SOUTH CAROLINA WINS AN UGLY ONE, BUT SELLERS SHOWS HIS HEART

South Carolina defeated Texas A&M 17-9, and while it certainly wasn’t an offensive masterpiece, there was something about the performance that impressed me.
LaNorris Sellers.
Sellers was far from perfect. His accuracy remains inconsistent, and his receivers were still having to dig some throws out to help him.
But the young man is a freaking warrior.
Playing on a bad ankle, Sellers continued battling when his team needed him most.
There are things about his development that still concern me. I’ve been pretty vocal about those concerns throughout the season.
But nobody should question his toughness.
Sometimes football isn’t about looking pretty. Sometimes it’s about finding a way to win when your body is telling you that you’ve had enough.
Sellers did that Saturday.
And he deserves credit for it.
THE COMMITTEE HAS A MESS ON ITS HANDS
Here’s where things get interesting.
Miami loses. Ohio State loses. Ole Miss gets demolished. Kentucky gets embarrassed.
Meanwhile, Notre Dame, Georgia, Oregon and Tennessee deliver statement victories.
Texas survives another week. Alabama strengthens its résumé. UCLA and Utah remain undefeated.
And Indiana, sitting at No. 4 entering the weekend, didn’t even play.
That’s an awful lot for the committee to sort through.
My biggest criticism of the playoff rankings has always been the apparent inconsistency in how teams are evaluated.
Sometimes strength of schedule matters. Sometimes it doesn’t.
Sometimes quality wins carry enormous weight. Other times, a team’s reputation seems to matter more.
And sometimes I wonder whether the committee is evaluating the football teams we’re actually watching or the football programs it expected to be good before the season started.
Those are two entirely different things.
MY TAKE: NOVEMBER DOESN’T CARE ABOUT REPUTATIONS
I’ve been around football long enough to know that championship teams aren’t crowned in September or October.
They’re revealed in November.
This is when the injuries accumulate, the pressure intensifies and every weakness becomes a target for an opposing coaching staff.
This is when offensive lines have to control the line of scrimmage, defenses have to get stops and quarterbacks have to make plays when everything around them is falling apart.
And this is when the pretenders start disappearing.
Georgia looked like a championship contender Saturday.
Notre Dame looked like a team that belongs in the playoff conversation.
Oregon proved that rankings mean absolutely nothing once the ball is kicked off.
And UCLA and Utah continued doing the one thing that ultimately matters most.
Winning.
The playoff committee will release another set of rankings, and we’ll spend another week debating whether it got them right.
But after what happened Saturday, one thing is abundantly clear.
The committee may have had its rankings figured out last week. College football apparently had other plans.
James Baxter | JB Talking Sportz


