November Has Arrived, and Nobody Is Safe

By James Baxter | JB Talking Sportz

November has arrived in college football, and if there’s one thing I’ve learned from watching this game for more than five decades, it’s that November has a way of separating the contenders from the pretenders.

Coaches who were considered geniuses a couple of years ago are suddenly looking for employment. Teams that were supposed to compete for national championships are fighting to remain relevant. And the College Football Playoff committee has released its first rankings, giving us plenty to argue about between now and December.

We’ve got a lot to talk about this week, so let’s get to it.

THE FALL OF MIKE NORVELL

Three years ago, Mike Norvell had Florida State sitting at 13-0, celebrating an ACC championship and wondering how an undefeated Power Five conference champion could possibly be excluded from the College Football Playoff.

Today, Norvell is unemployed.

Let that sink in for a moment.

Florida State fired Norvell on Sunday after a 3-5 start, ending his seven-year tenure with a 41-39 record. Rick Stockstill will serve as interim head coach while the Seminoles begin searching for someone to rebuild a once-proud program.

I’ve been around football long enough to understand that coaches get fired. It’s part of the business. But what happened at Florida State deserves a closer examination.

This wasn’t simply a football program that suddenly forgot how to win games.

The Seminoles went from 13-0 in 2023 to missing bowl games in consecutive seasons, followed by another disappointing campaign in 2026.

That’s not a decline. That’s a collapse.

And while some will continue pointing toward the playoff snub as the beginning of Florida State’s downfall, I’m not buying the idea that one decision by a committee destroyed an entire football program.

The transfer portal, roster management, recruiting evaluations, player development and coaching decisions all contributed to this mess.

The real question isn’t why Florida State fired Mike Norvell.

It’s how Florida State allowed things to deteriorate this badly before making the decision.

THE PLAYOFF COMMITTEE IS ALREADY MAKING ME SCRATCH MY HEAD

The first College Football Playoff rankings were released Tuesday, and I’m already questioning some of the committee’s thinking.

Miami sits at No. 1, followed by Georgia, Utah and Indiana.

Fine.

But explain something to me.

How does undefeated UCLA, sitting at 8-0, find itself ranked eighth while Alabama, with two losses, sits at No. 5?

And while we’re asking questions, how does Ohio State, which defeated Indiana earlier this season, find itself eight positions behind the Hoosiers?

I understand strength of schedule. I understand quality wins. I understand that not all records are created equal.

But at some point, winning football games has to matter.

I’m not suggesting that an undefeated team automatically deserves to be ranked ahead of every team with a loss. That’s ridiculous.

What I’m suggesting is that the committee needs to demonstrate some consistency in how it evaluates teams.

The SEC placed 10 teams in the initial Top 25. That tells us something about the committee’s respect for the conference.

But respect for a conference shouldn’t become an automatic advantage for every team playing in it.

I’ve always believed that what happens between the white lines should carry more weight than the name printed across the front of a jersey.

Apparently, that’s still open for debate.

OHIO STATE HAS A PROBLEM

Ohio State’s 30-18 loss to Southern California did more than damage the Buckeyes’ playoff position.

It exposed some concerns about a team that entered the season with championship expectations.

Everybody wants to talk about quarterback play when a talented team loses. And certainly, the quarterback position deserves scrutiny.

But I have a bigger concern.

Defense.

You don’t surrender 30 points in a game of that magnitude and then place all the blame on your offense.

Championship football teams have to be capable of winning games when their offense isn’t functioning at its highest level.

Ohio State is now 6-2 and sitting at No. 12 in the initial playoff rankings.

The Buckeyes aren’t finished, but they’ve placed themselves in a position where every remaining game becomes critically important.

And Oregon comes to Columbus this weekend.

There’s nothing quite like a wounded football team being forced to face another dangerous opponent before it has time to recover.

We’re about to find out a great deal about Ohio State’s character.

THE COACHING HOT SEAT IS GETTING CROWDED

Mike Norvell may be the biggest coaching casualty of the week, but he’s certainly not the only coach feeling pressure.

Oklahoma’s Brent Venables has to be feeling the heat after another disappointing performance, including the Sooners’ loss to South Carolina.

And there are other programs around the country where athletic directors are undoubtedly examining the direction of their football operations.

Here’s something that continues to fascinate me about modern college football.

Universities are handing coaches enormous contracts with guaranteed money, only to discover a few seasons later that they may have made a mistake.

Then they spend millions of additional dollars to make that mistake go away.

Imagine running a private business that way.

College football has become a billion-dollar industry, but some of the financial decisions being made within that industry would make an accountant reach for a bottle of aspirin.

The next coaching hire is always supposed to be the one who restores the glory.

Until he isn’t.

SOUTH CAROLINA HAS AN OPPORTUNITY TO CHANGE ITS SEASON

I’ve been critical of South Carolina this season, and I believe that criticism has been justified.

The Gamecocks have struggled with consistency, offensive execution, penalties and questionable decisions at critical moments.

But I’ll also give credit where credit is due.

Carolina’s 42-25 victory over Oklahoma was significant.

The Gamecocks are now 5-3 and have entered the initial playoff rankings at No. 21.

And suddenly, there’s an opportunity to turn what appeared to be a disappointing season into something considerably more interesting.

Texas A&M comes to Columbia this weekend.

This is the kind of game that can change the narrative surrounding a football program.

But I want to see more than a few spectacular plays from LaNorris Sellers.

I want to see an offense that functions efficiently for four quarters. I want to see receivers catch footballs they’re supposed to catch. I want to see an offensive line that gives its quarterback an opportunity to operate.

And I want to see a defense that doesn’t require a miracle every time the opponent enters scoring territory.

South Carolina has enough athletic ability to compete with good football teams.

I’ve never questioned that.

What I’ve questioned is whether this team can consistently execute the fundamentals necessary to beat them.

Saturday provides another opportunity to answer that question.

LANE KIFFIN AND THE LSU EXPECTATION

Lane Kiffin has never been a boring football coach.

He’s innovative offensively, understands quarterback play and has demonstrated an ability to create problems for opposing defensive coordinators.

But coaching at LSU comes with expectations that go well beyond putting up impressive offensive numbers.

The Tigers are 6-2 and ranked No. 14 entering Saturday’s showdown with Alabama.

And this is precisely the kind of game LSU expects its head coach to win.

I’ve always appreciated Kiffin’s offensive creativity. He’s one of the better minds in the game when it comes to identifying defensive weaknesses and creating favorable matchups.

But there’s a difference between being a brilliant offensive coach and building a championship football program.

The latter requires consistency in recruiting, development, defensive performance and the ability to win games when your offense isn’t clicking.

Alabama provides Kiffin with an opportunity to make a statement.

It also provides us with another opportunity to evaluate whether LSU is developing into the kind of program its supporters expect.

MIAMI MAY BE NO. 1, BUT I’M NOT SOLD YET

Miami is undefeated at 8-0 and occupies the top position in the College Football Playoff rankings.

That’s an accomplishment worth recognizing.

But the Hurricanes’ narrow 38-35 victory over North Carolina raised some questions for me.

Championship teams don’t have to dominate every opponent. Sometimes winning ugly is part of becoming a champion.

But there’s a difference between surviving an occasional bad afternoon and developing a habit of allowing inferior opponents to hang around.

Miami travels to Notre Dame this weekend in one of the biggest games on the schedule.

And the Irish, ranked No. 11, have plenty of motivation themselves.

I want to see how Miami handles adversity against a quality opponent on the road.

I want to see whether the Hurricanes can control the line of scrimmage, protect the football and avoid the defensive breakdowns that nearly cost them against North Carolina.

Miami may very well be the best team in college football.

But I’m not ready to hand the Hurricanes a trophy just because a committee placed them at the top of a list.

They still have to earn it.

GEORGIA AND OLE MISS: SOMEBODY’S PLAYOFF DREAMS ARE TAKING A HIT

Georgia travels to Ole Miss this weekend in another matchup with enormous playoff implications.

The Bulldogs are ranked second nationally, while Ole Miss sits at No. 10.

I’ve always believed that November football is won by teams capable of controlling the line of scrimmage and protecting the football.

Explosive plays are wonderful. Everybody loves a 70-yard touchdown pass.

But when the weather changes, the pressure increases and every possession becomes more valuable, football has a tendency to return to its fundamentals.

Can you run the football when the opponent knows you’re going to run it?

Can you protect your quarterback?

Can you stop the opponent on third down?

And can you avoid making the kind of mistakes that turn a close game into a loss?

Georgia has built its reputation around physical football, defensive discipline and roster depth.

Ole Miss has the opportunity to demonstrate that it belongs among the nation’s elite.

This should be one of the most revealing games of the weekend.

ONE FINAL THOUGHT: THE UCLA QUESTION

Before I wrap things up, I want to return to something that bothers me about the initial playoff rankings.

UCLA is undefeated.

Eight games. Eight victories.

Alabama has lost twice.

Yet Alabama is ranked three spots ahead of the Bruins.

Maybe the committee has a perfectly reasonable explanation based on the strength of the two schedules.

I’d simply like to hear it.

Because if we’re going to tell young men that every game matters, then we need to make certain that every game actually does matter.

Otherwise, we’re moving dangerously close to a system where preseason expectations and conference affiliations carry more influence than the results on the field.

And that’s not what college football should be about.

BAXTER’S FINAL BLITZ

We’re entering the stretch of the season when reputations mean less and results mean everything.

Mike Norvell has already discovered how quickly fortunes can change.

Ohio State is fighting to remain in the championship conversation.

Miami is trying to justify its No. 1 ranking.

Georgia, Alabama, LSU, Notre Dame and Ole Miss are preparing for games that could dramatically alter the playoff picture.

And South Carolina has an opportunity to prove that its recent improvement is something more than a temporary flash.

November doesn’t care what you were ranked in August.

It doesn’t care how much money your coach makes.

And it certainly doesn’t care how many five-star recruits you signed.

It only cares what happens when the football is kicked off.

And that’s exactly why I love this time of year.

James Baxter
JB Talking Sportz

jbtalkingsportz.com

BAXTER’S BLITZ